Philanthropic foundations are private institutions that reside uneasily in the public sphere, where they perform crucial functions—supporting social services large and small that state institutions cannot or will not provide, making possible arts and other cultural enrichment programs, even enacting ambitious programs of social reform. In short, they contribute significantly to the public good. Yet they are in some ways profoundly undemocratic institutions in their structure: they are privately controlled and therefore generally outside the typical accountability mechanisms that are an important hallmark of other types of organizations and institutions in democratic society. Their legitimacy thus cannot derive from conformity with democratic processes, but must rest on the performance of special roles or functions that are socially useful and broadly acceptable.
The SSRC, in collaboration with the Mattei Dogan Foundation and the Russell Sage Foundation, convened a workshop in 2004 at which an interdisciplinary group of scholars specializing in philanthropic organizations and the non-profit sector in the United States and Europe presemted new work on the complexity and multi-dimensionality of foundations’ public and private roles. These scholars joined policy makers and representatives of important European and American foundations in discussing the functions and legitimacy of philanthropic organizations in contemporary society.
Contributors
-
Kenneth Prewitt, “Functions and Legitimacy of Philanthropic Foundations in Contemporary Society”
-
David Hammack, “American Debates on the Legitimacy of Foundations: Historical Perspectives”
-
Giuliani Gemelli, “Historical Changes in Foundation Functions and Legitimacy in Europe”
-
Margaret Wyszomirski, “The Role of Foundations in Supporting the Arts and Culture in the US”
-
Elisabeth Clemens, “Public, Private and Philanthropic Roles in American Education”
-
Rupert Strachwitz, “The Role of Foundations in Supporting Culture and Science: A German and European Perspective”
-
James Allen Smith, “Social Diversity and Foundation Legitimacy in the US”
-
Filip Weijkstrom, “Foundations in a Social-Democratic Welfare-State Regime: The Case of Sweden”
-
Julian Wolpert, “Redistributional Effects of Foundations in the US”
-
Steen Thomsen, “Industrial Foundations: Foundation Ownership of Business Companies in Northern Europe”
-
Kirsten Grønbjerg, “Foundation Legitimacy at the Community Level: US Case”
-
Diana Leat, “Foundation Legitimacy at the Community Level: The United Kingdom”
-
Peter Frumkin, “The Impact of Regulation on Foundation Practices in the US”
-
Yannick Blanc, “State Tutelage and the Protection of Private Foundations: The Case of France”
-
Helmut Anheier, “Foundations and Civil Society”
-
Olivier Zunz, “Commentary on the Field Studies: A Comparative History of Philanthropy”
Social Science Research Council